I have read all 7 pages thus far and this is my assumption, note the word "assumption". I believe Mr. Sully has his mind secretly already made up, however he wants us to recommend what he has already decided on with out having influenced our recommendation of it. Thusly, justifying his decision with out "solicitation" by so called "experts".
Mr. Sully, I would never twist another firearms enthusiast's arm to choose what I like. However, I once again am going to make an assumption. And here it is, be it right or wrong(which is very possible, I must admit). I believe that you may possibly be under educated on the wonderful world of AR's and a tad closed minded on the subject as well. We all had at one time the same mind set as you on them at one time, but after much research, "most" of us came to the realization that for what it is we do....they are the nearest thing to ideal as can be had, and bit the bullet(so to speak) and are the happier for it.
Please don't take this as an "Attack" on you or as being derogatory in any way, that certainly is not my motive. I am very happy that you are here, and look forward to the exchange of future info with you. My sole motive is the possibility of pointing out something you may or may not have thought of....so you and I can both make more informed decisions in the future.
Chupa