Gee Curt, did you get up on the wrong side of the bed this AM?
I'm one of the people that have experienced a surface blow up with a V-Max - first hand.
You mentioned shooting too far, I think the opposite is more the problem. I shot a coyote heading straight at me at a range of about 35 yards and placed the shot perfectly.
This was at a very modest 223 velocity.
If I have it scanned I could send you a very graphic picture showing why I tend to avoid them.
Compared to your numerous good results this is a very small sample but I must say that it made an unfavorable impression on me.
Due to the fact that I had called that coyote within about 35 yards I don't think that bullet's failure could be blamed on my inability to call. Due to the fact that the bullet hit exactly where I aimed it; dead center of the chest, I don't think that my markmanship caused that bullet failure.
I don't think they have the build to stand up to much bone at close ranges/high velocity.
The flip side - I have a buddy that loads 40 grain V-Maxes at an absolutely screaming velocity out of a 220 Swift and swears by them. He shoots coyotes that are targets of opportunity - almost always at some very extended ranges. One small hole in, no exit.
I'm setting on hundreds of loaded V-Max rounds left over from a canceled p-dog shoot, perhaps I should give them a fairer shake. I just have to get over what I considered a gross failure in a circumstance where I have seen the more traditionally constructed 52's, 53's, and 55's poke a little hole going in and set the coyote down on the spot w/o much more than a wiggle.
I guess if you shoot any bullet enough you'll see some unexplainable or unexpected performance - maybe I just happened to see it out of the V-Max at the opening bell?
Peace.