I've owned, built, or fired hundreds of AR's. I've never thought the trigger guard was so important of a difference to ever care about so much. Open or closed - who cares? Done a lot of shooting AR's with gloves, never ever needed to open my guard, so once I pin it in and snap it in place, it might as well be closed. Never broken a pinned guard, so I can't say any strength increase would be an advantage.
Mostly seems like a marketing gimmick - answer to a question nobody asked.