Originally Posted By: Tbone-AZI would carefully measure the advice given by anyone that suggests using polyurethane on a gun stock.
That's pretty funny spoken by the guy who used some sort of blue body filler gunk in his fine wood working to fill in the cracks in the wood. Whatever you want to say about my wood working advice is fine, but I am far too much of a perfectionist to use blue filler on nice looking wood.
I will stand by Minwax Wipe On Poly as one of the easiest and toughest stock refinishing materials out there for someone who wants a quick and easy tough finish that is far better than the factory finish used by Remington. I have received two messages from guys who tried it and loved the results, but who were undoubtedly afraid to post those replies after reading your attacks to the subject.
Hey, that table looks nice (with the exception of the blue goo), but you do not want to put it up against the kind of furniture work I do. I would not have trashed your work or ideas had you not been doing that to me, perfect example is that you bring my name in a derogatory light into a discussion that has nothing to do with me, not exactly a class act to be sure.
I have been complimentary about your work because you enjoy what you do and it makes no sense to trash someone's hobby.
The rifle stocks I did professionally for people were done with hand rubbed oil finishes, and would not have been appropriate for a casual refinish for most people, which is why I shared the best easy finish I've found since many oil type finishes were banned here.