After researching a lot of different load data, I settled upon 18" for my new 6.8. I had a 16" SPC I, but wasn't too impressed with what the original specs could do, so I sold it off. Now I'm seeing SPC II's out there doing considerably more. I decided upon 18" because I knew I didn't want longer than 20", but I saw data that I considered to be reliable suggesting only 15-30fps difference per inch between 18" and 20" and I knew that I wanted a brake on this one. Ultimately, I'll have a 20" nose sticking out, with 18" velocity, still pushing a couple hundred feet per second faster than my old 6.8spc.
Then again, I suppose some will accuse me of crippling my new 204 Ruger barrel too, since I only bought it in 22". Stuff has to be portable after all...