Originally Posted By: filmitOriginally Posted By: Winny FanI apologize in advance, but a top end custom Mauser rifle like I was describing is far far from a $1K rifle.
Granted, the Whitworths are and were at the top of the Mark X food chain in terms of Mauser action factory rifles built on the Mark X action. But, in today's world they lack a lot in comparison to a full custom Brevex or a fully modified FN for example that will have custom bottom metal in the white and before engraving, etc. that costs considerably more than a Whitworth rifle in full bloom with its factory "they all look alike" bottom metal, for example.
In reality, the Mauser of any sort is falling behind in custom rifle builds very quickly these days to more modern action designs. It's been going on for probably the past 15 years or so, and as the supply of good Mausers dries up, so too will the number of new customs built on a Mauser action.
Agan, a Mark X, even in a Whitworth rifle, of which I own several excellent examples, are still a Nova in a world where true Cadillacs do exist. Again......The price differences between them are considerably and perhaps mind blowing for some people. But that is reality.
You are comparing apples to oranges here. Comparing an out of the box Whitworth to a custom Mauser or "fully modified FN". Now show me a factory out of the box rifle made today in the $1,000 price range that is anywhere the quality of a Whitworth, it doesn't exist. And yes I have a few custom Mausers including a pair of 404 Jeffery's that you couldn't touch for $5,000 a piece. But that's not what the OP asked. Mark x actions are a great solid action, especially considering the price you can find them for. Are they the best for a light weight sheep gun, no, but the OP didn't specify what kind of build he's thinking of.
IIRC, you are the one who started the apples to oranges comparison using the Whitworth rifles because you didn't like my Cadillac to Nova comment. All I said along those lines is that for a full custom Mauser that I'm talking about that, and since you tossed out dollars, your $5k price wouldn't buy the stock let alone a highly customized action and barrel and bottom metal to go with it. Think $20K+ to whatever your heart desires and your check book allows. In that debate, your Whitworth orange becomes a wrinkled apple very quickly.
All my original comments were about is the fact that the quality of the Mark X actions has varied over the years. I never said they are junk, just look for a good one if that is the route you're going. And then came the Whitworth comment which is your opinion. Fine and good. But it's probably not everyone's opinion.
Since you mentioned this too, and since I've actually done it, I'd hope I could find a much better platform to build a light-weight sheep rifle on than a heavy Mauser action of any make.
And please enjoy your Whitworths. I like mine too, but they are nothing special in the entire realm of things built on a Mauser action or any other action for that matter. Not even close. Kinda' like a Cadillac and a Nova. You might enjoy this link. Just don't offer anyone $5k for anything you see here or offer a dozen Whitworths in trade. You might get some strange looks.
http://www.acgg.org/
Here's a link to the work of an ACGG member. Notice he passed on Mark X actions for well built military actions complete with stripper clip thumb slots for the most part. Maybe he hasn't heard of a Mark X or a Whitworth. Or maybe he knows what works best for building a full custom rifle from. Knowing his reputation and his work, I'd guess its the latter.
http://www.customgunmaker.com/examples.html
Enjoy your weekend. Maybe next week we can debate how many fairies can fit on the head of a pin. You go first again.