First off, just enjoy the trip, the scenery, and the memories you'll make. Dont go with any intention of killing a elk. Yes, hunt hard and do your best, but dont base the trip as "good or bad" on whether or not you get to kill a elk. Your in for future dissapointment if you do.
I've only hunted one place around Pagosa. Up around Monument Park up above the Piedra river. Seems like we went west out of Pagosa and then turned back up just on the east side of the river. Drove a long way back in there, then at the trail head we went horseback another hour to monument Park and set up camp. It was a good trip, several nice bulls killed.
I'm dying to go during one of the rifle seasons!! My buddy had to cancel on our Sept 14 Archery trip and I've been upset ever since. I want to go so freaking bad, but not up for the drive from Oklahoma alone.