I like subsonics out of the Ruger for early season. I have a DRock bullet modification system that I flatten the top and hollow-point with. Makes a world of difference in "terminal performance". I actually use quite a bit of Remington's SS. But I also use some Aquila, PMC Match Pistol, Federal AutoMatch, Wolf MT, Federal Gold Medal... With the Hollow Pointer they all make good hunting ammo.
The Annie gets SK HV HP. Shoots it like a laser and I normally use it more later in the season after the leaves come off and the ranges tend to be a bit longer.
I know what you mean about accuracy. My 1422 will shoot bugholes at 50 meters - but heck - the Ruger will shoot cloverleafs.. Pretty good squirrel medicine and fun to shoot.
What do you shoot for ammo? How about a picture of the Annie?