My $.02
Many years ago, I was a lowly novice civil servant with a "modest" income. (quotes indcate extensive sarcasm here...)
I had an old stevens .243 that was my deer rifle (also anything that required more than a .22 rifle.)
The rifle came with an older Weaver fixed 4 power scope, and less than a month before deer season opened, I managed to break the reticle.
Weaver had transferred all of their manufacturing overseas, but still had (and have, to my knowledge) facilities in El Paso. I called them, and they had me ship them the scope. They replaced the fine crosshair, and all the seals. They recharged it with nitrogen and polished it up pretty as could be.....and didn't charge me a dime. I had the scope back on the rifle before deer season, and couldn't have been more pleased. All I paid was shipping.
I now have two other fixed Weaver 4x on both of my "walking" guns. You can find these inexpensively, and know that the old El Paso steel tubes all had a lifetime warranty, that this company still honors. I haven't had to send another one in, but for the money, if I was looking to go to a fixed power scope, I can't reccomend a used Weaver K4 or K6 enough.
That being said, I have a Leupy MKIV on my tactical .308, and numerous Nikons and Leupolds on my assorted Rem 700s.... As has been mentioned many times, it's all about application.
Watch the yard sales and community boards.
WNYS