I think the new Velocity Reticle that Matt mentioned in his first post is a great reticle too. Very cutting edge stuff there. I've looked through a NightForce with the reticle & it appears fantastic. Not shot one though.
The reason I mentioned the F1 Mildot is because I personally get along with it very well. Not because it's not the cheapest out there, or because it has only tactical applications, because it doesn't.
I personally don't own a "tactical rifle". I used to have a couple, but mine are all hunting rifles now.
It seems to me that when something is lauded as being fantastic under "tactical" situations, then it would really stand out for hunting applications as well.
Now, in my opinion, targets are a totally different matter. If I want to do serious target competition, I'll want a very fine, precise reticle that allows me to pinpoint where the bullet is going to hit without covering any more of the target than needed.
I think it may be my eyes that lends me to love the F1 scopes. I don't have to hunt for the crosshairs when things get fast and furious.
Plus, if a scope has ranging capabilities, I don't want to be limited to just ONE power setting. I think it's great that the F1 works of ALL power settings.
The 3.5-15x50 is a 'beefy' scope. Not overly so, but bigger than the 2.5-x32 you mentioned. I just personally like more lens on the business end than 32mm. Again, just a personal choice.
On my bolt guns, like you guys, I want the scope as close to bore as possible. On AR's it's gonna be off the bore, so why not go with a large objective?
I took off a 3-9x40 Leupold and went with a 3-9x50 Bushnell Elite on my Sav. M10FP. It does fantastic as well. It's the only rifle I have that will shoot with my custom AR with the F1 NightForce on it.
As Matt said, he needs to go to the site and browse the choices. There's lots of them. Thank God we are not stuck with just a couple. Everyone is different in what they need & like. Thank goodness we are not stuck with having to use the old "deer rifle" scopes that we had to use in the past.
Barry