personally I like higher magnification too a certain point, but the reticle also matters as well as far as small groups go. I have a 4-14x scope with a range finding reticle that the reticle gets larger as you go up in power, which gives you very heavy bars at 14x. The bars probably cover an inch at 100 yds. So far I can still shoot better groups with a 3-9x on paper, but in real hunting situations I like the higher power, most of the time.