Salty,
Most of the reservations in AZ do NOT have open regulations for non-tribal members. The ones that do, like San Carlos, get called as much or more than the rest of the state.
I grew up in Globe AZ and have hunted on San Carlos all of my life. I still like going there and calling, but I run into more predator callers out there than anywhere else. There is a false sense among some callers that becasuse it's a reservation, no one must be calling it - not so. It's not any diferent than bass & crappie fishing - when San Carlos Lake is hot, you can almost walk across the lake on the boats.
Here's an interesting note - Our log books for the past 3 seasons show better success rates on an animals called per stand basis when calling off the reservation than on - quite a bit better.
Now then - I'd bet calling on some of the closed reservations, in AZ and elsewhere areound the US, would be awesome beyond belief. Kinda like the coyote stampedes in Mexico. Can a tribal member on a reservation get on edge over guys who aren't allowed to hunt there? Sure they can. Lots and lots of predators with virgin ears would have to equal big success.
I really like calling on San Carlos, as do many, many other hunters. It's easy to get addicted to the large expanses of open land. But, I'm sure I'm not alone in saying it's not a magic bullet - it gets called quite a bit. Heck, the PM hunt has been held there several times - it's a fun place to call, but it's certainly not a secret spot.
Best regards,
Mark Healy